Scarlett Johansson Catherine
Liev Schreiber Eddie
Jessica Hecht Beatrice
Alex Cendese Submarine
Michael Cristofer Alfieri
Anthony DeSando First Immigration Officer
Antoinette LaVecchia Mrs. Lipari
Matthew Montelongo Tony
Submarine
Mark Morettini Mr. Lipari
Joe Ricci Mike
Morgan Spector Rodolpho
Corey Stoll Marco
Robert Turano Louis
Marco Verna Second Immigration Officer
Understudies: Alex Cendese (Tony, First Immigration Officer, Second Immigration Officer, Submarine), Bonnie Dennison (Catherine, Mrs. Lipari), Jim Iorio (Louis, First Immigration Officer, Second Immigration Officer, Mr. Lipari, Submarine, Mike)