American Buffalo Booth Theatre Previews Began: October 20, 1983 Opening Night: October 27, 1983 Closing Night: February 4, 1984 Tickets 0.0 Rated 0 out of 5 Add To Watchlist Please login to bookmark Username or Email Address Password Remember Me Playwright: David Mamet After underselling a valuable nickel to a customer, junk shop owner Don and a team of third-rate crooks plot to seek revenge by stealing the customer’s coin collection. CAST OPENING NIGHT Al Pacino Walter ColeJames Hayden BobbyJ. J. Johnston Donny DubrowUnderstudies: Ralph Monaco (Donny Dubrow), John Shepard (Bobby) REPLACEMENTS Bruce MacVittie Bobby 11/11/1983 – 2/4/1984 OTHER PRODUCTIONS 1977 Broadway 2008 Broadway 2022 Broadway Your review Your overall rating Select a Rating5 Stars4 Stars3 Stars2 Stars1 Star Submit your review