Christy Altomare Sue Snell
Corey Boardman George
Carmen Cusack Lynn Gardner
Jeanna de Waal Chris Hargensen
Blair Goldberg Norma
F. Michael Haynie Freddy
Derek Klena Tommy Ross
Marin Mazzie Margaret White
Andy Mientus Stokes
Elly Noble Helen
Molly Ranson Carrie White
Jen Sese Frieda
Ben Thompson Billy Nolan
Wayne Wilcox Mr. Stephens
Others
Understudies: Mackenzie Bell (Lynn Gardner, Chris Hargensen, Frieda, Helen, Norma), Corey Boardman (Tommy Ross), Jake Boyd (Tommy Ross, Mr. Stephens, Freddy, George, Stokes), Blair Goldberg (Chris Hargensen), Andy Mientus (Billy Nolan), Elly Noble (Sue Snell, Carrie White), Jen Sese (Carrie White), Anne Tolpegin (Margaret White, Lynn Gardner)