Jenni Barber Sundown LeMay
Daniel Breaker Lee
Ari Graynor Peeps
Cheyenne Jackson Mandrew
Alicia Silverstone Sara
Henry Winkler Chuck Wood
Understudies: William Hill (Chuck Wood), Mark Junek (Mandrew, Lee), Ariana Shore (Peeps, Sundown LeMay), Kaily Smith (Sundown LeMay, Sara)